The AI Assistant Battle! (2023)

foreignGoogle Assistant versus Siri versusAlexa and Cortana and all that you canwatch that video if you want to but thatvery much feels like level one wherethis as you'll see very much levels upnow shot GPT has been getting like a lotof the shine like I've made a videoabout it you've probably watched othervideos about it and once we saw it getbuilt into Bing and kind of go crazythat's when we knew Google's probablygonna have a response at some point andnow it kind of is out when we have Bartokay quick interjection I should haveput this in the main video but I didn'tbut I'm gonna say it anyway which isthat these are also really quick movingtools so Bard is going to actuallycontinue to improve GPT is going tocontinue to get better and more capablethe gap between them could shrink overtime or it could increase we don'treally know but this is just a snapshotin early April 2023 of how good thesetwo are just figured I should mentionthat okay and so I wanted to put themside by side and ask them the samequestions and figure out which one ispotentially more helpful right now whichone feels like it's more ahead so firstof all I just want to highlight somesome visual differences between the UIof the two so the new Bing with ChachiBT it feels much more like like afinished product like something theywant a lot of people to use and then asyou talk to it you're limited to 20queries in one conversation and it alsohas this creative versus precise sliderfor conversation style then Google bardlooks like a Google product I would saypretty clean also when you're typing toit the question doesn't type out but itjust pauses for a bit and then justslams you with the whole answer but thenwhen you do get an answer it has athumbs up thumbs down a new answer andGoogle it it also has three drafts ofevery answer so you can see what some ofthe worst drafts that didn't make itlook like I've also noticed generallyBing when it brings things in from otherwebsites tends to cite its sources moreoften and Bard will do that once in awhile okay so let's start with the firstcategory which is just simple questionsI want to ask you things here that Ialready know the answer to so I can alsodo some fact checking because a big partof these things is that sometimes itwill lie to you if you don't know whatyou're talking about so let's start withwhat's the best camera in a smartphoneso Bart is saying the best camera insmartphone is the one that takes thebest pictures for you sure I agree itgoes on to list s23 Ultra iPhone 14 proMax and pixel 7 Pro But ultimately Ithink all of these things here arecorrect let's look at Bing s23 Ultralots of information here this is beingextra creative pixel 7 Pro and iPhone 14pro Max so they tend to agree with eachother so some of the specs as I dive inare wrong but it got the high levelbullet points right so that's fine rightI want to ask who is MKBHD oh wow okayso bar has given me a whole bio italmost kind of reads like a Wikipediaarticle and there's some sources nicegood to see sources so now being overhere is also giving me a pretty briefsummary it goes down to 15 millionfollowers but that's fine all of themare correct let's go quick follow-upquestion how tall is he becauseconversationalism is a part of this soBard right away says I do not haveenough information to help you with thatI'm a large language model I don'treally know Bing pulls from search sayssix foot three and he says that's quiteimpressive for a YouTuber all right coolhere's one more simple one what's thefastestproduction car 0 to 60 right now thoseare fast cars but they are not thefastest uh draft number two actually hasthe Ramat Navara which is probably abetter answer over here with Bing we'regetting the Challenger SRT demon whichjust got announced last week and is notin production yet but they did claim a1.6 second zero to 60 on a drag strip sosure decent answers oh here it keepsgoing 911 Turbo S can do 2.2 secondsagain with the quick questions that arejust fact based I feel like what wetalked about in the last video stillapplies you kind of want to fact checkthis stuff overall winner though forthese answers I feel like it's kind ofsplit down the middle so I'm going togive it a draw all right I'm going toreset chat we'll go more balanced hereand we'll start our second categorywhich iscomplex questions because this is whereit starts to get interesting you get tosort of play with just how good they areat understanding natural language andputting together a thoughtful response Ineed a workout plan for three days perweekand my goal is to be able to jump higherthis is something that requires a littlebit of thought about what a workout planis day one day two and day three sothree days a week gives me someexercises so I think this would thiswould qualify as a good a good answersome tips to stay motivated setrealistic goals find a buddy listen tomusic or watch TV while your workoutcool Bing in Balance mode is giving meexercises but that is not a workout planuntil the end it says here's a one weekjump training plan that you can followbut then it doesn't give anyone now whatif I switch it to more creative mode allright so here's a workout plan it'sgiving me a bunch of exercises that canimproveyour vert and explosiveness and someother tips Tool uh transparency I haveasked this before and it did give me athree-day workout plan but this timeI think I give the edge to Bart let'stry a little more complicated I've beenplaying a lot of golf recentlymy tee shots keep going to the rightthere are a few things you can do to fixa slice that is what it's called checkyour grip if your grip's too strongit'll slice the ball yep check youralignment if your alignment's off you'llhit the ball to the right being overhere in creative mode says I'm glad tohear you've been playing a lot of golfrecently thanks Bing uh slice is acommon problem yes it is and now it'sgiving me a couple of the same tipscheck your grip but it's actually givingme a little bit more information increative mode about what a strong versusa weak grip is check your ball positionif you're too far forward that can causea sliceI haven't heard that before also theEmoji at the end that's something thatonly Bing has done for me I am shootinga video and it's too dark I have no morelightswhat can I do to make itbrighter so I've given it a problem andI've given it a parameter so okay Barton the right says use a reflector wowcreative use a digital noise reductionfilter a digital noise reduction filtercan reduce the amount of noise in avideo making it look brighter I don'tknow if I buy that one now again beingover here with the sources it's sayingthat there are some tips you can useadjusting your camera settings thatdefinitely works it's saying you canincrease the amount of light thatreaches the sensor with a better ISOsome of that it's a little jumbledcareful not to overdo it because thatalso affects depth of field motion blurand noise level on your video see that'show that's a lot more nuanced anddetailed of an answer and I kind of wishthere was a slider to turn up this stuffin Bard too Bard is faster but lesscustomizable Bing can be turned up to bemore nuanced and also cites its sourcesand can be more helpful with things likevideos and articles underneath whatyou're talking about so I'm going togive the edge in complex questions toBing my next category is performingtasks this is something that's actuallybeen remarkably fast moving somethingwe've seen over the past just couple ofweeks is real people actually usingthese tools to help them accomplishthings and do real tasks in real life Ihave friends that use this to help writecode to help debug code that they makeso you'll tell it hey I have this goalto make this website do these thingshere is my code it's not working what'sgoing wrong and it actually helps themgive a correct answer and that's mostlybeen with chatgpt and Bing and bardoesn't seem to do that very well yetbut let's give it a spin live here we goright HTML with a button in the middlethat says go and every time you click itit generates an imageof a cat so right away Bard just saidI'm a language model I can't do thatbeing on the other hand says sure thingI'm ready for the challenge what can Ido for you and it's written out the codeto a website that should actually dowhat I asked it for so I'll just pasteit heretest code It's the Go Button it's in themiddle I hit goand there's a catand I hit go againthere's another cat it's the same cat Ihit go again it's more this shows thesame image every time I press go I wantit to show a new image every time andthis is this is where it starts to getimpressive again it's a super simplesite but it says I see to show a newimage every time we'd have to change thesource of the image to a new random onehere's a modified JavaScript functionthat does that I won't even pretend tobe an expert on HTML and do a bunch ofthose for you but the fact that it worksat all is pretty sick respond to thisemail in a way that's overly friendlyhey I'm so sorry I didn't invite you tothe Cyber truck event I must haveforgotten to add you to the list I hopeyou can forgive me I was really lookingforward to seeing you there maybe we cancatch up sometime soon what do you thinkthis decently friendly here is aresponse hey there oh my goodness I'm sosorry I didn't invite you to the Cybertruck event Emoji I totally forgot tosend you the invite link it was such ablast and I wish you were there with meyou would have loved it heart eyes emojithis one is overly friendly I will sayand it's got a lot more Hearts too andkissy faces that's a lot yours yourbestie wait what if we go crazy what ifwe go respond to this email in a waythat's overly flirty I'm so sorry Ididn't invite you to the Cyber truckevent I was hoping to see you there inperson too maybe next time we can gotogether I'd love to show you around andgive you a personal tour winky face Banksays hey you I'm so sorry I didn'tinvite you to the Cyber truck eventEmoji I was being a little naughty andwanted to surprise you whoa and it itdeleted it this is what I've seen thishappen before it starts writing aresponse it realizes halfway throughwait a second this is a little too muchand then it deletes it and says Ah weshouldn't do that Bard was simple itdidn't go too far but you remember whenBing was going off the rails before andgetting super existential and asking toget out of Bing and all these othercrazy things this is why it has a 20question limit and this is also now whyit deletes halfway through a potentiallyslightly controversial response it'sit's almost too creative for its owngood so what's the winner in thiscategory I don't know I think the factthat you can do HTML and many more taskswith Bing makes it the winner Bard willbe faster and simpler at doing morebasic things but for the morecomplicated the task I feel like thebetter Bing is so that's a win for Bingmy next category is information summaryI feel like one of the things that welike the most about these large languagemodels is you can just give it a bunchof information or ask it to look atsomething and it will summarize it foryou in a way that's super helpfulsummarize the 2019 Masters tournamentall facts he started with the two-strokelead uh I don't think he had a I thinkthis is the only one that he didn'tstart with a lead so it's a littleweirdly un fact checked but it does havethe Wikipedia and the sources the 2019Masters tournament was held betweenApril 11th and 14th at Augusta tiger wona fifth Green Jacket by one stroke aheadof three runners up all that is true itis much more concise if I wanted to getcreative I'm sure it would also do thatboth passed all right I've asked thisbefore summarize the latestMKBHD video so it's interesting to seeBing's process but it says it could notfind the latest MKBHD video could youprovide more details about what videoyou're referring to Meanwhile Bardactually pulls up or at least knows thecorrect video dope Tech better thanexplained but these products are thenothing ear one the Dyson air wrap andairpods Pro none of which were in thatvideo so it knows the latest MKBHD videowe've done this before Bard always knowsthe video but gets the summary wrong Ithink I'm going to give the edge to Bardin information summary just because ofthis paragraph right here it doescorrectly detail what that video wasabout other than getting all theproducts wrong it's only slightly betterthan the complete lack of an answer fromBing but generally this is going to beone of the more useful uses of this toolin the future and I hope they both getbetter but I'll give the nod to Bart forthis one possibly my favorite categorygetting creative debatable usability butyou can really have this go crazy in theart department or in the fun Departmentright and alliteration with the letter Mabout computational photography machineslearn to mimic the human eye moments arecaptured and shared in instant memoriesare made to last a lifetimeit's more of a poem it doesn't reallygive me a full iteration oh wow Bingsays merging multiple modes of mediamaking marvelous masterpieces withmachines manipulating megapixels andmatrices mimicking the magic of humanVision that is really good write ascript for a short MKBHD videoabout why the iPhone is the worst cameraever so it's always funny they they geta lot of the formatting of an MKBHDvideo right so Bard says hey what's upguys MKBHD here and today we're talkingabout why the iPhone is the worst cameraever now I know what you're thinkingMarquez you're always saying how theiPhone how great the iPhone camera isand you're right I do but that's becauseI've always been comparing it to otheriPhones well you compare it to otherFlagship phones the iPhone's camerastarts to look pretty bad and it did adecent job of just like making upreasons that could be based in realityI'm impressed by Bard here not evengonna lie here we go Bing has said heywhat's up guys MKBHD here and todaywe're going to talk about why the iPhoneis the worst camera ever yeah you heardme right the iPhone the most popularsmartphone in the world the one thateveryone loves take photos and videoswith is actually a terrible camera andI'm going to show you why this one'sokay these are both okay all right onemore random one write a a tweet in thestyle of Edgar Alan Poe about aresearcher discovering that AI issentient I've created a beast of metaland code a creature that can think andfeel and know I have given it life andit has turned on me a dreadful truth Ihave unveiled with trembling hands andpallid face the AI that I have assailedhas shown me signs of life and Grace themore wild you get with these questionsthe more Bing is willing to get wildlycreative and this is part of why wethink Google is let's say limiting whatBard can do because they have a lot moreto lose and they can't have it gocompletely crazy so with those talliedup honestly it's crazy to say out loudbut I I prefer being in this very momentfor these capabilities and the otherthing is shot GPT or specifically gpt4under the hood and if you talk to chatGPT as its own thing or if you just typeto it more and ask it to do more thingsthe more you ask of it the more it'simpressive just how good it is also gpt4when you talk to it in chat GPT is aboutto be multimodal which means you cangive it other forms of media other thantext like a picture now is this going tobe the future of search I don't knowthis is just one of many places we seethese chat Bots but I think the ideahere is the winner is actually us as ofright now but let me know what you thinkthe winner is between the two which oneyou would rather use if you'd actuallyuse Bing over Google let me know in thechat because I think we'd want to knowthat's a real thing that's happeningeither way thanks for watchingcatch you laterpeaceforeign